WageKit
Payroll TaxPTO & BenefitsHiring & OnboardingHR TemplatesWorkplace RegulationsView all guides →
Payroll Tax CalculatorSSP Calculator 2026Holiday EntitlementPAYE Calculator 2026/27Employer NI CalculatorRedundancy Pay CalculatorMaternity Pay CalculatorLeave Accrual CalculatorNotice Period CalculatorPTO Accrual CalculatorHandbook GeneratorCompliance AuditView all tools →
Employment ContractDisciplinary & GrievanceAnnual Leave PolicyGDPR Privacy NoticeOnboarding ChecklistProbation Review FormExit Interview TemplateView all templates →
NewsletterWrite For UsFree Payroll Calculator
All comparisons
Comparison

Xero vs QuickBooks Payroll: Which Is Best for UK Small Businesses in 2026?

Two accounting giants with built-in payroll. We compare Xero and QuickBooks side by side to help UK small business owners pick the right platform for paying their team.

Our pick

Xero — tighter UK integrations, better ecosystem of third-party payroll add-ons, and a cleaner interface for growing teams.

FeatureXeroQuickBooks
PricingFrom $15/mo + $5/employeeFrom $14/mo (payroll included)
UK payroll support✓ Add-on module✓ Built into plans
HMRC integration✓ Direct RTI filing✓ Direct RTI filing
Employee self-service✓ Via Xero Me app✓ Workforce portal
Onboarding✗ Manual setup✗ Manual setup
Time off management✓ Basic leave tracking✓ Basic leave tracking
Reporting✓ 50+ payroll reports✓ Standard reports
Mobile app✓ iOS & Android✓ iOS & Android
Free trial✓ 30-day free trial✓ 30-day free trial
Best forGrowing SMEs with accountantsSole traders & micro businesses

Xero Payroll: Detailed Review

What it does well

  • Clean, modern interface that accountants and bookkeepers love
  • Vast app marketplace with 1,000+ integrations
  • Direct HMRC RTI filing and year-end submissions
  • Xero Me employee app for payslips, leave requests, and expenses
  • Strong multi-currency support for international invoicing alongside payroll

Where it falls short

  • Payroll is an additional cost on top of base subscription
  • No built-in onboarding workflows or HR management
  • Customer support wait times can be long during peak periods

UK-specific considerations

Xero is deeply embedded in the UK accounting ecosystem. Most UK accountants use or recommend Xero, which makes collaboration easy. It handles P45s, P60s, student loan deductions, and workplace pension auto-enrolment with providers including Nest and The People's Pension. Xero also supports Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) deductions.

Pricing breakdown

Xero's base plans start at $15/month (Starter), $30/month (Standard), and $47/month (Premium). Payroll is an add-on at approximately $5 per employee per month. For a 10-person team on the Standard plan, expect around $80/month total.

Our Pick

Xero

The UK's most popular cloud accounting software. Add payroll for seamless HMRC compliance.

Try Xero Free →

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you.

QuickBooks Payroll: Detailed Review

What it does well

  • Payroll included in most plans at no extra cost
  • Step-by-step payroll wizard ideal for non-accountants
  • Automatic tax calculations and HMRC RTI submissions
  • Strong invoicing and expense tracking alongside payroll
  • Cash flow forecasting tools built into the dashboard

Where it falls short

  • Smaller third-party app ecosystem compared to Xero
  • Reporting is less customisable for complex payroll scenarios
  • Fewer UK accountants use QuickBooks, making collaboration harder

UK-specific considerations

QuickBooks handles all standard UK payroll requirements including RTI, auto-enrolment pensions, student loan deductions, and statutory payments. It generates P45s and P60s automatically. QuickBooks is particularly strong for sole traders and micro businesses that want accounting and payroll in one affordable package.

Pricing breakdown

QuickBooks Simple Start is $14/month (1 user). Essentials is $27/month (3 users). Plus is $38/month (5 users). Payroll is included in all plans at no extra charge for the first year. After the promotional period, payroll may be priced separately.

Best Value

QuickBooks

All-in-one accounting and payroll for UK sole traders and small businesses. No payroll add-on fees.

Try QuickBooks Free →

Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Xero if...

You work with a UK accountant (they likely prefer Xero), need extensive integrations, or are a growing SME that will benefit from the larger app ecosystem and more advanced reporting.

Choose QuickBooks if...

You are a sole trader or micro business owner who wants accounting and payroll in one package without add-on fees. Great if you manage your own books and want a guided experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Xero payroll included in the subscription?+
No. Xero charges payroll as an add-on at around $5 per employee per month on top of your base accounting plan. The payroll add-on includes RTI filing, payslip generation, and pension management.
Does QuickBooks handle HMRC RTI submissions?+
Yes. QuickBooks Payroll files RTI directly with HMRC, including Full Payment Submissions (FPS) and Employer Payment Summaries (EPS). It also handles year-end reporting.
Which is easier for a non-accountant to use?+
QuickBooks is generally considered more intuitive for non-accountants thanks to its step-by-step payroll wizard. Xero has a cleaner interface but assumes slightly more payroll knowledge.
Can I switch from QuickBooks to Xero mid-year?+
Yes, but mid-year migration requires importing year-to-date figures for each employee to ensure correct tax calculations and RTI continuity. Both platforms offer migration tools, but it is advisable to do this at the start of a new tax year (April) if possible.
Do both support workplace pension auto-enrolment?+
Yes. Both Xero and QuickBooks support automatic enrolment and integrate with major UK pension providers including Nest, The People's Pension, and Smart Pension.